I’ve had my kids’ bath toys organized the same way for years. About every 6 months (usually while my girls are in the tub) I dump all of their toys on a towel and go through them. I get rid of stuff they aren’t playing with anymore and put away toys that aren’t for the tub that always somehow make their way into my “tub toy” bins. Because I sort through these toys so often it’s a quick ten minute job.
I keep all of the bath toys under one of the bathroom sinks. I keep the lids off so that they are easy for the girls to grab and put away.
After bath time we always toss the toys in the sink. Then after the toys have dried off (for the most part) one of us tosses them in the bins. Letting the toys dry out a little keeps them from getting mildew-y. Is mildew-y a word? I guess it is on this blog.